Sunday, September 20, 2015

Journal Analysis!


Twilight
Amanda Peck
HUMN 240
Deborah Brushaber
September 17, 2015

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

The article I chose was Twilight:The Glamorization of Abuse, Codependency and White Privilege by Danielle N. Borgia.  This article is about the Twilight series which is four books, turned into movies, written by Stephenie Meyers.  This series is about a girl, Bella, her vampire crush who ends up her husband, Edward, and a friend who has feelings for Bella, Jacob, who is a werewolf.  Bella is your normal every day teen girl living in Forks, Washington.  Edward on the other hand is a very wealthy, handsome, white male.  Jacob is also very handsome, he is a Native American, who does not have as much as Edward.  The movie makes a very big point that Edward has more than Jacob.  He has a beautiful home, drives very fancy cars, and has everything anyone could ever want.  Jacob drives an older vehicle and lives in a lower class house.  The movie makes a point that these guys are on opposite ends of the spectrum.  Bella falls in the middle.  Another main point of the article is that Bella and Edward are very codependent on each other.  When Bella sleeps, since Edward does not need sleep, Edward watches her.  When he has to leave town, he pays his sister to keep an eye on Bella.  It can be looked at as Edward is very dominating to her.  She feels like nothing without him.  Edward is also somewhat abusive to Bella.  After they are married and they are intimate for the first time, Bella wakes up with bruises all over her body.  Edward feels like a monster, but Bella tells him it is fine.  This is a cycle that is seen in an abusive relationship. 

            The author has many strong points, but she also has good evidence to back her points up.  The title of the article is Twilight:The Glamorization of Abuse, Codependency and White Privilege, and Borgia proves that the Twilight series does “glamorize” abuse, codependency and white privilege.  “Edward’s treatment of Bella is recognized as abuse by the people that love her (Borgia pp 163).”  When she gets invited to go somewhere, she has to okay it through Edward, not her father.  “The young female protagonist is needy, ‘‘weak, unobser-

vant, and almost ridiculously dependent,’’ as Jana Riess has firmly as-serted.”  Bella lets Edward control her life.  She makes no decisions for herself and lets Edward make them all.  Edward is also very privileged.  He lives in a beautiful house, drives a fancy car and has everything anyone could want.  When he has to leave town, he offers his sister a Porsche to watch over Bella.    Jacob is one of Bella’s friends that has a crush on her.  He is a Native American that is also a werewolf.  Jacob does not have everything like Edward.  He also cannot control turning into a werewolf like Edward can control not drinking Bella’s blood. 

            I do agree with Borgia’s points about the movie/books.  The series does glamorize abuse, codependency and white privilege.  I do not agree that this is how the world should be but I do think that this is how the series portrays Edward and Edward and Bella’s relationship.  I think that this is not a good series for young girls to get into after reading the article.  Edward’s lifestyle is very emphasized.  The fact that Bella and Edward are codependent is a large part of the series. 

            I think that this article is important.  I used to love the Twilight series but after reading this I have a different opinion.  Young people are easily influenced and I do not think that this is a good influence for teens.  Women should not think that it is okay to be controlled by their partner.  People should not be looked at as more privileged because of the color of their skin.  It is important to show that some people do think this way and make an opinion of if you think that this is appropriate or not.  I think this is a good article to read before you let your older children watch this movie.

 

 

REFRENCE

Borgia, D., (2014). Twilight:The Glamorization of Abuse, Codependency, and White Privilege. The Journal of Pop Culture. 47(1) pp 153-173

 

No comments:

Post a Comment